The Exculpation of Circumstances

,
Lately I have been reading and thinking about the level of influence circumstances have on emotions. There is a distinction that needs to be made between feelings and emotions. Feelings are stimuli we receive from the world around us. Emotions are conscious responses to such stimuli. Some people argue that some emotions are inevitable; however, that has always seemed to me as contrary to an inherent property of being human: The eternal truth of agency. If circumstances were to define how we are to react to stimuli, then we would lose our freedom of choice. Circumstances, defined as the existing conditions surrounding an agent, may only affect him or her to his degree of allowance. They may not impose or define his or her actions, emotions, and desires. These are therefore rooted in aspects of consciousness and under the control of oneself. So, experiencing emotions of boredom, anger, sadness, disappointment, happiness, love, or hatred, is our choice. I do recognize that it is easier to blame the circumstances for what happens to us and for our state of mind, but the responsible thing is to choose what state of mind we want to be in every minute of our lives.

2 comments:

Rachel Leta said...

Hm... You make a good point. I think the problem is how hard it can be to not keep emotions from coming in. Sometimes it's good for them to be there, but oftentimes we've connected emotions to feelings so much that when feelings come up, the emotion is triggered to come up too.

Caitlin said...

I found this an absolutely fascinating view on emotions and feelings. It's really actually a very good way to describe everything. (That sounds like I'm surprised that you could come up with something like this...I'm not.) I am, however, very happy that you posted this. It helps. Although, I do have to agree with Rachel in the sense that we do, as humans, connect certain situations with certain feelings and certain feelings with certain emotions. Sometimes it's hard to break that pattern.

Post a Comment